Browse By

Visible Minorities: On Naomi Osaka Heckling

SNA (Tokyo) — At a recent tournament in Indian Wells, California, Japan tennis champion Naomi Osaka was heckled by some troll in the audience who shouted out “you suck!” while she was playing on court.

That reduced Osaka to tears. She asked the referee if she could address the crowd, then asked to have the troll ejected. Both requests were denied, and play resumed. Osaka then lost in straight sets.

In post-game comments, Osaka tearfully noted the distraction and compared her situation to a 2001 incident where Venus and Serena Williams faced crowd abuse, again at Indian Wells. The Williamses boycotted the venue for more than a decade after that.

Fortunately, this time Osaka’s heckler was the outlier. The audience at the venue, fellow players afterwards, media and internet chatter were overwhelmingly supportive of her.

Still, others noted that Osaka needs to develop a thicker skin.

I’m afraid I agree.

Osaka has been around on this circuit for quite a while. She’s now 24, and obviously has the talent to be world champion. Now the question is, does she have the mettle to maintain it?

Remember, these are the choices she made: As I wrote in a September 2018 Japan Times column–“Warning to Naomi Osaka: Playing for Japan Can Seriously Shorten Your Career”–it was her decision to represent Japan, a country with a long history of putting grueling (and sometimes fatal) pressure on its athletes. They’re expected to put their country first and their personal welfare a distant second.

And it’s further complicated by the fact that Osaka is a Visible Minority in Japan, moreover living the preponderance of her life in America and still lacking proficiency in the Japanese language.

That means, like for so many Visible Minorities in Japan, her foreignness is tolerated only so long as she keeps winning. Put simply: If she wins, her Japanese half is celebrated. If she loses, her Non-Japanese half is to blame.

And, right now, she’s not winning. She’s skipped tournaments due to mental health issues and has underperformed in the recent ones she’s attended. Despite having the honor of lighting the Olympic flame in Tokyo 2021, she only made it to the third round in the tennis event. Currently she’s fallen to 78th in the world rankings.

That is tragic, especially since her Japanese sponsors will eventually start questioning their investment’s value, as she’s the highest paid female athlete in history.

She’s also used her status (rightly) to openly advocate for minority causes in America, including Black Lives Matter (but notably, not for fellow Visible Minorities in Japan; she even ironically dismissed racism in Japan as merely a matter of “a few bad apples”).

But here’s the point: What is Osaka’s goal?

If she wishes to settle for the celebrity, or the status of “famous for being famous,” then mission accomplished. Tennis or no tennis, she can continue to attend gala events and model for magazine covers and advocate for her causes.

But if she wishes to remain a tennis champion, especially one representing Japan, and compensated by Japanese firms, then she’s going to have to develop greater focus.

No matter what, there will be detractors. That’s the hazard of being a public figure. Her off-court comments on human rights issues, etc. will gain even more detractors.

I speak from some experience here: While I am not an athlete and cannot claim to be a world champion at anything, I too have fought for human rights causes in Japan. I’ve maintained a sustained public campaign against racial discrimination in Japan for decades, writing several books, and garnering domestic and international media attention regarding “Japanese Only” signs and rules. We took our case all the way to Japan’s Supreme Court and made it clear to the world, despite all the denials, that racial discrimination is an embedded, systemic reality in Japan.

This too brings forth detractors who think that pointing out something shameful in Japan is shameful in itself. As do the trolls of the Global Far Right, who hold up Japan as their model ethnostate, and from them I get death threats on a weekly basis.

But my goal has always been straightforward: Get a national law passed against racial discrimination in Japan with criminal penalties. It might not happen in my lifetime, but that remains my focus and I pay the trolls little heed.

At some point in time Osaka has to stop letting hecklers take her power away. This is that point in time.

If it’s a matter of unfairness in the rules, or something that targets her because of things she cannot change (such as her racial and ethnic background), then by all means, protest that. Racism should never be tolerated.

But a matter of a generic “you suck!”, while unpleasant and undeserved, is something people her age should have learned to deal with.

Bullies will always exist, and you’ll probably encounter them outside of Indian Wells. Showing them that they have the power to affect you like that only emboldens them further. Reclaim that power by showing them you’re stronger than they are. Be unfazed. Otherwise you will appear to lack the mettle to stay champion, and they, not you, will accomplish their goals.

Yes, it’s Indian Wells’ job to create a comfortable and level playing field for athletes, and they should have taken responsibility for that. It’s our job as the general public to make sure those conditions are in fact enforced and to support our favorite athletes. If Indian Wells isn’t going to cooperate, then yes, boycott the place.

But it’s still the athlete’s job to train both physically and mentally and play their personal best.

So do your best, Naomi Osaka. Achieve what you can, tune out what you can’t. That’s what champions do. It’s the path you chose, and to a certain degree these detractors come with it.

As you might say, dismiss them in your mind as just “a few bad apples.”

For breaking news, follow on Twitter @ShingetsuNews